06 Dec Review
The review institute, governed by article. 309 c.p.p., constitutes one of the fulcrums of the system of precautionary guarantees in the Italian criminal trial, as it allows for rapid judicial review, effective and full on ordinances that provide measures restrictive of personal freedom, in implementation of the articles. 13, 24 e 111 Cost. and the articles. 5 e 6 of the ECHR, requiring that any restriction of freedom be subjected without delay to scrutiny by an independent judicial authority. The rationale for the review clearly emerges from the preparatory works of the code 1988, which abandons the conception of precautionary measures as merely functional tools for repression, placing them instead within a system of protections marked by the principles of necessity, proportionality and adequacy, then further strengthened by reforms regarding pre-trial detention (L. 332/1995, L. 8/1995, L. 47/2015). The review discipline is characterized by the rigidity of the deadlines and the stringent procedural structure: within ten days of notification or execution of the precautionary order, the suspect or his lawyer must lodge a request, under penalty of inadmissibility, while the judge who issued the order must send the documents to the competent court within five days, a term that the Constitutional Court has qualified as peremptory and to guarantee the effectiveness of the control, establishing that its violation determines the automatic loss of effectiveness of the measure (Corte Cost., n. 233/2011; n. 188/2010). This automatic lapse has led the jurisprudence of legitimacy to qualify the term as “decadence of public order”, also removed from the availability of the suspect and insusceptible to elastic interpretations (Cass., Sez. WE, n. 24247/2014). The trial before the Review Court - a collegial body made up of three magistrates, whose third party is considered essential pursuant to art. 111 Cost. – takes place according to chamber of commerce forms, but with fullness of the contradictory, allowing the defender to examine the documents, the production of documents, the presentation of briefs e, mostly, the possibility for the suspect to make spontaneous statements to integrate or contest the precautionary framework. The content of the court's control has undergone a significant jurisprudential evolution: initially intended as a merely formal review of the adequacy of the motivation, today it is configured as a real judgment of a substantial nature, in which the reviewing judges can and must directly evaluate the evidential elements underlying the serious indications of guilt pursuant to art.. 273 c.p.p., as clarified by the United Sections in the "Constantino" ruling (Cass., SS.UU., n. 11/1995) and reiterated in the “Timpanaro” (Cass., SS.UU., n. 5876/2004), who stated that the motivation for the precautionary order must be autonomous and not merely representative of the PM's requests, under penalty of its illegitimacy. Furthermore, European jurisprudence has accentuated the guarantees of precautionary risk by placing emphasis on the obligation to provide reinforced reasons for measures restrictive of personal freedom, particularly in cases of custody in prison, requiring that precautionary needs be current, concrete and not deducible from stereotyped formulas (CEDU, Italy v. Santoro, 2004; Letellier c. France, 1991). On the merits, the Review Court is called upon to verify the existence of serious indications of guilt, which the Court of Cassation defined as a "serious" evidentiary framework, accurate and consistent” (Cass., Sez. WE, n. 2244/1996), as well as the existence of the precautionary requirements typified by the art. 274 c.p.p. – danger of escape, evidentiary pollution and repetition of the crime - reaching an overall judgment of proportionality and adequacy of the measure pursuant to art.. 275 c.p.p., which requires the judge to apply the least distressing measure sufficient to guarantee the precautionary needs, in line with the principle of the "minimum indispensable sacrifice" repeatedly reiterated by the Constitutional Court. The court can then set aside the order, modify or replace it, and its decision can be challenged with an appeal to the Court of Cassation, limited to defects of legitimacy, pursuant to Article. 311 c.p.p., while any revaluation of merit is precluded. Such a multilevel control system, completed by the precautionary appeal of the art. 310 c.p.p. – dedicated to rejection decisions, replacement or revocation of the measures - reflects a precise guarantee architecture that the legislator and jurisprudence have progressively refined to prevent the precautionary measure from, especially custody in prison, turns into an anticipation of the sentence or an abuse of investigative authority. As a whole, the review pursuant to art. 309 c.p.p. it is not just a procedural tool, but a constitutional safeguard that protects personal freedom and ensures respect for due process, ensuring that each restriction is supported by effective reasons, by a solid evidentiary framework and current precautionary needs, according to a model of the rule of law that does not tolerate arbitrary or uncontrolled restrictions.